There are only three types of ideas.

There are some ideas which are really smart ideas that sound smart on the surface and people repeat them to each other over and over again. If you come up with that smart idea independently, then you will tell someone and they’ll go “yeah, that’s already been thought of already, see X”. Using Vitamin C to prevent scurvy, realizing that worrying doesn’t make a situation better and stopping yourself from being a “nice guy” if you ever want success with women are all examples of this. These are not the ideas you have to be worried about.

There are some ideas which are stupid and sound stupid on the surface. If you come up with that stupid idea independently, then you will tell someone and they’ll go “that’s stupid and here’s why”. Here are 10 of them. These are not the ideas you have to be worried about.

There are some ideas which are stupid but sound smart on the surface. If you come up with that stupid idea independently, then you will tell someone and they will go “huh, that’s interesting”. These are the ideas you have to be worried about because they are the persistently stupid ideas. Persistently stupid ideas come to a person, are tried, fail and then disappear, leaving very little trace of their existence after they are gone. As a result, each generation comes up with the same persistently stupid ideas anew and wastes energy and resources chasing the same illusory pot of gold. This is why you have to be worried about them. The only way to avoid persistently stupid ideas is to learn how to become reflexively allergic to stupid.

I harp on this same theme a lot but I’m writing about it today because I was exposed twice in the same hour to two different persistently stupid ideas. Now, since both the people who these came from are personal friends of mine, I want to emphasize that I think the ideas presented are stupid but I, in no way, think the people who sent these to me are stupid. In fact, I discuss this further below. Anyway, onto the stupidities:

The first is an NPR article that repeats the assertion that when our privacy disappears, maybe shame will disappear along with it.

The second is an email in which in which a friend extols the virtue of video chat:

video chat is even better because the software just fades away and it’s true communication. It doesn’t require building software to support intent, it just creates a wide enough channel for communication and gets out of the way.

Both of these are persistently stupid ideas but I’m not going to tell you why they’re persistently stupid ideas.

Because what I just realized about persistently stupid ideas is that they’re perversely more harmful to smart people that dumb people. Each of these persistently stupid ideas has 100 different reasons why they could be wrong. But 99 out of those 100 aren’t the real reason and they don’t stand up to scrutiny.

If you were dumb and you came to be with a persistently stupid idea, I could take pity on you and provide you with any one of those reasons and you would accept it as valid and gently be persuaded from taking the stupid path. However, if you’re smart, I know that you’re going to see through any of the bad arguments and I would be forced to come up with the one correct argument to satisfy you.

But the truth is, I’ve forgotten what the reason is that both of these are a persistently stupid idea. At one point, I had read the literature, carefully constructed the argument, considered it from all sides, correctly rejected all the wrong arguments against it, worked through the implications of the correct reason, concluded that it was a persistently stupid idea, then promptly emptied out my brain of all that datum except that it was persistently stupid.

As a result, I’m not even going to try and persuade you that these are persistently stupid ideas. If you don’t believe me, you’re just going to have to put in your own time and effort to independently investigate them. However, the smarter you are, the harder it will be for you to figure out why they are persistently stupid because you will correctly reject all the utterly random, poorly thought out shit people pull out to justify it’s stupidity.

This is, perhaps, why I’m so fascinated by this topic of stupidity. Because it’s a unique curse that, paradoxically, affects the smartest of us the most.

  • http://blog.ginsudo.com ginsu

    What about ideas that are really smart but sound stupid on the surface? Seems like many startups that were ultimately successful were once regarded as stupid.

  • Yel

    This is a stupid post. But the truth is, I have forgotten the reason why. At one point, I had read the literature, carefully constructed the argument, considered it from all sides, correctly rejected all the wrong arguments against it, worked through the implications of the correct reason, concluded that this was a stupid post, then promptly emptied out my brain of all that datum except that it was persistently stupid.

  • Nick Thomas

    I have found one of these persistently stupid ideas. It specifically afflicts mystically inclined (invariably male) individuals who try to change the world. This persistently stupid idea is that of inventing a new vocabulary in order to explain the universe. The reason it is stupid is that that vocabulary will never make as much sense to anybody else that it made to you, even though this fact will never be visible to you because it makes perfect sense to you. The result of this persistently stupid idea that the one afflicted devotes their life to explaining the universe in this new vocabulary and then leaves behind only half-comprehensible fragments of truth. Examples of this phenomenon include Aleister Crowley, G.I. Gurdjieff, the early Wittgenstein, Martin Heidegger, and Jean-Paul Sartre.

  • Nick Thomas

    I have found one of these persistently stupid ideas. It specifically afflicts mystically inclined (invariably male) individuals who try to change the world. This persistently stupid idea is that of inventing a new vocabulary in order to explain the universe. The reason it is stupid is that that vocabulary will never make as much sense to anybody else that it made to you, even though this fact will never be visible to you because it makes perfect sense to you. The result of this persistently stupid idea that the one afflicted devotes their life to explaining the universe in this new vocabulary and then leaves behind only half-comprehensible fragments of truth. Examples of this phenomenon include Aleister Crowley, G.I. Gurdjieff, the early Wittgenstein, Martin Heidegger, and Jean-Paul Sartre.

  • Nick Thomas

    I have found one of these persistently stupid ideas. It specifically afflicts mystically inclined (invariably male) individuals who try to change the world. This persistently stupid idea is that of inventing a new vocabulary in order to explain the universe. The reason it is stupid is that that vocabulary will never make as much sense to anybody else that it made to you, even though this fact will never be visible to you because it makes perfect sense to you. The result of this persistently stupid idea that the one afflicted devotes their life to explaining the universe in this new vocabulary and then leaves behind only half-comprehensible fragments of truth. Examples of this phenomenon include Aleister Crowley, G.I. Gurdjieff, the early Wittgenstein, Martin Heidegger, and Jean-Paul Sartre.

  • Lijing1821839896
  • http://www.domain2host.in domain registration india

    These information helps me consider some useful things, keep up the good work.

  • Sunlimei1989

       
    “Which of the horses has ugg boots cheap sale he taken?” I asked carelessly.   
    “None of them,” she replied. “He went away two hours since on foot. As I understood it, his object was to make fresh inquiries about the woman named Anne Catherick. He appears to be unreasonably anxious about tracing her. Do you happen to know if she is dangerously mad, Miss Halcombe?”   
    “I do not, Countess.”   
    “Are you going in?”   
    “Yes, I think so. I suppose it will soon be time to dress for dinner.”   
    We entered the house together. Madame Fosco strolled into the library, and closed the door. ugg boots on sale I went at once to fetch my hat and shawl. Every moment was of importance, if I was to get to Fanny at the inn and be back before dinner.   
    When I crossed the hall again no one was there, and the singing of the birds in the library had ceased. I could not stop to make any fresh investigations. I could only assure myself that the way was clear, and then leave the house with the two letters safe in my pocket.   
    On my way uggs discount to the village I prepared myself for the possibility of meeting Sir Percival. As long as I had him to deal with alone I felt certain of not losing my presence of mind. Any woman who is sure of her own wits is a match at any time for a man who is not sure of his own temper. I had no such fear of Sir Percival as I had of the Count. Instead of fluttering, it had composed me, to hear of the cheap uggs online errand on which he had gone out. While the tracing of Anne Catherick was the great anxiety that occupied him, Laura and I might hope for some cessation of any active persecution at his hands. For our sakes now, as well as for Anne’s, I hoped and prayed fervently that she might still escape him.   
    I walked on as briskly as the heat would let me till I reached the cross-road which led to the village, looking back from time to time to make sure ugg boots discount outlet that I was not followed by any one.   
    Nothing was behind me all the way but an empty country waggon. The noise made by the lumbering wheels annoyed me, and when I found that the waggon took the road to the village, as well as myself, I stopped to let it go by and pass out of hearing. As I looked toward it, more attentively than before, I thought I detected at intervals the feet of a man walking close behind it, the carter being cheap uggs online in front, by the side of his horses. The part of the cross-road which I had just passed over was so narrow that the waggon coming after me brushed the trees and thickets on either side, and I had to wait until it went by before I could test the correctness of my impression. Apparently that impression was wrong, for when the waggon had passed me the road behind it was quite clear.

  • http://www.tgc-anaheim.com/ チュニック

    Thanks for your great post.I like this very much, please write more about these, wait for your update.

  • http://www.register-web-domain.in/ Domain registration

    I am so glad this internet thing works and your article really helped me,thanks for presenting.