I first discovered this obviously wrong truth when I was doing my honors thesis. Time and again, I would come up with a novel idea or a neat algorithmic trick. Some of them, I would discover had already been invented 3, 5, sometimes 10 years before I came up with it. But the ones I was absolutely sure nobody had published before because I had scoured the literature and covered every approach. Well, all of those original ideas turned out to have some hidden, unforeseen flaw that rendered them either trivial or actively stupid. This lead me to formulate the belief that “anything you think is either unoriginal, wrong or both“. Like all obviously wrong truths, it has the paradoxical property of being obviously wrong and also true.

The premise for the statement comes from the simple observation that good ideas survive and bad ideas die. This means there exists an entire class of awful ideas that people come up with time and again only to eventually discover their wrongness and then abandon them. Every person who discovers them believes themselves to be wholly original since nothing of the sort exists in the world and each of them is met with disappointment, sometimes after many years of sweat and toil. But because failures are almost invisible, they leave no warning signs to future generations that this is an awful idea that should be avoided*.

Anything you think is either unoriginal, wrong or both” is an acknowledgment of your own stupidity. Your first instinct, when you come up with a new idea, should be to try and find out if anyone else has done it before. Your second instinct should be to try and find out if anyone’s done it before. Your third, forth and fifth instincts are to ask how come everyone else figured out this was a dumb idea and I haven’t? If you’ve gotten this far and you still haven’t discovered anything useful, you should start feeling a little bit uneasy, it probably means you weren’t smart enough to discover how wrong you are.

If you have discovered the prior art or the fatal flaw, then breathe a small sigh of relief. Unoriginal ideas are GOOD, wrong ideas are GOOD. An unoriginal but right idea is still valuable to all the other people who’ve never heard of it and chances are, if you’ve never heard of it, there will be a significant fraction of the population to which bringing this idea contributes value. Wrong ideas do more to teach you more about the world than right ideas because they teach you about some discrepancy between your expectations and the world, The corrective force of wrong ideas is what allows you to deftly cut to the core of any issue and tease out just where assumptions are weak and likely to fail.

But if you’re lucky, over the course of your life, you’re going to stumble across many ideas which are both original and right, in which case it’s still better to treat them as unoriginal and wrong. Believing an idea is unoriginal and wrong makes that idea do more work. You attack it more fiercely and from more angles. You keep on asking people if the idea sounds familiar and you’re eager to seek feedback because you’re so damn curious to discover why it could be so wrong yet elude you for so long. In doing so, you disassociate the idea from your ego so that you can take criticism about it calmly and dispassionately. Eventually, that drive of curiosity will force you to action, just to finally prove how this idea is flawed. Treating an idea as unoriginal and wrong means that the only standard you’re willing to accept is success. This brings a clarity or purpose that cuts through the confusion when executing upon that idea. Other people may be willing to make excuses or caveats that salve their ego but, as far as you’re concerned, if an idea is not successful, it’s not right**.

Anything you think is either unoriginal, wrong or both” is an idea that also applies to itself. I’ve been slowly chewing over this idea for almost four years now and it’s been frustrating to me that so far, I haven’t been able to find someone else that’s expressed it as a similar sentiment which by de facto, makes it wrong. I’m putting this out there to invite the embarrassment of someone pointing out the obvious source or the obvious flaw that I’ve managed to miss for so long. Please, tell me how I’m stupid, it would be a welcome relief.

*Some people, when first discovering this problem, come up with elaborate schemes of recording all of these common awful ideas so that future generations can avoid them. This, unfortunately, is a common awful idea.

** not right and wrong are different concepts in the same way that not being a millionaire is different from being homeless.

Responses

  1. Petey Wheatstraw says:

    June 12th, 2009 at 2:07 pm (#)

    Forwarded to my entire office, thanks!

  2. Petey Wheatstraw says:

    June 12th, 2009 at 6:07 am (#)

    Forwarded to my entire office, thanks!

  3. Alan Watts says:

    June 12th, 2009 at 9:05 pm (#)

    Ideas are neither right nor wrong in an absolute sense. What is right in one circumstance is wrong in another. What was true yesterday is false today.

    Conditioned co-production … states that all things arise in dependence on conditions, and cease when those conditions cease. Things have neither absolute existence nor absolute non-existence – they have relative existence.

    Ultimate reality is inexpressible (though millions of people claim to express it and blog it daily) … but

    I am sure you’ll figure this shit out, because you have taken the first step. You have opened the gateless gate.

  4. Alan Watts says:

    June 12th, 2009 at 1:05 pm (#)

    Ideas are neither right nor wrong in an absolute sense. What is right in one circumstance is wrong in another. What was true yesterday is false today.

    Conditioned co-production … states that all things arise in dependence on conditions, and cease when those conditions cease. Things have neither absolute existence nor absolute non-existence – they have relative existence.

    Ultimate reality is inexpressible (though millions of people claim to express it and blog it daily) … but

    I am sure you’ll figure this shit out, because you have taken the first step. You have opened the gateless gate.

  5. Derrick Hiebert-Flamm says:

    June 15th, 2009 at 4:04 pm (#)

    I would like to piont out that, while this is largely true and has precedence (Edison or Bell did not invent many of the things tfor which they take credit), the role of the person who “rediscovers” something is to popularize it. If something is valuable and yet unknown, it might as well not have been invented. Therefore, discover something, see if it did any good, find some sort of application for it and make it popular. In so doing, you may think you are not original, but you actually are since you are taking an idea and actually doing something with it.

    By the way, sometimes when you come up with something and take a relatively new angle on it, you have to jump on the idea in order to get any play out of it. For me, I wrote my senior thesis on some ideas about globalization, ethnicity, inequality, and development. Almost immediately after finishing the thesis, I started seeing a million NEW works being discussed and some starting to get published. I was just part of a trend. Frustrating, but at least I know that I am either right or part of a very large group of wrong people.

  6. Derrick Hiebert-Flamm says:

    June 15th, 2009 at 8:04 am (#)

    I would like to piont out that, while this is largely true and has precedence (Edison or Bell did not invent many of the things tfor which they take credit), the role of the person who “rediscovers” something is to popularize it. If something is valuable and yet unknown, it might as well not have been invented. Therefore, discover something, see if it did any good, find some sort of application for it and make it popular. In so doing, you may think you are not original, but you actually are since you are taking an idea and actually doing something with it.

    By the way, sometimes when you come up with something and take a relatively new angle on it, you have to jump on the idea in order to get any play out of it. For me, I wrote my senior thesis on some ideas about globalization, ethnicity, inequality, and development. Almost immediately after finishing the thesis, I started seeing a million NEW works being discussed and some starting to get published. I was just part of a trend. Frustrating, but at least I know that I am either right or part of a very large group of wrong people.

  7. Danger359 says:

    July 4th, 2009 at 12:10 pm (#)

    Ideas are not unique. They happen when the preconditions for the idea exist and someone makes the intuitive leap. There are many examples throughout history. How many ideas did Leonardo have? How many were “discovered” later? Remember that most of Leonardo's work (the Codex) is missing. In science, many labs tend to discover the same results or reach the same or similar conclusions simultaneously. It then becomes a race to publication. This is also the case with inventions and the race to patent.

    Great blog. Keep it up!

  8. The Dream Job « Bumblebee Labs Blog says:

    August 5th, 2009 at 7:45 am (#)

    […] Dream Job is so stunningly obvious that it must be wrong. I can’t possibly have been the first person to have come up with this. But if it’s […]

  9. name says:

    February 13th, 2010 at 4:59 pm (#)

    Nil novus sub soli.

  10. Mayuri says:

    February 28th, 2010 at 5:19 pm (#)

    You've managed to express a very elaborate idea in a catch phrase 🙂
    Loved the post.

    PS: Why is recording one's errors “a common awful idea.” ?
    It saves time and resources for anyone else trying the same thing a few years later!
    In fact, this is one of the most common practices in science!

  11. Hang says:

    February 28th, 2010 at 8:17 pm (#)

    Can you point me to a repository of failed ideas? An encyclopedia of error? That it doesn't exist is proof that is one of those unoriginal & wrong things that people try & fail to create again & again.

  12. Mayuri says:

    March 1st, 2010 at 2:16 pm (#)

    There is no repository because mistakes are not going to be glorified..but they are recorded and difficult to find. Recording mistakes is not an awful idea.

    A famous example would be the two proposed models for structure of the Deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA).
    We all now know that the DNA is a double helix as what was suggested by Watson and Crick in their publication (http://osulibrary.oregonstate.edu/specialcollec…)

    However, there is available information about the triple helix model proposed by Pauling and Corey. http://osulibrary.oregonstate.edu/specialcollec

    It gives a perspective about how data was interpreted at the time and saves anyone new from coming to the same wrong conclusion.

  13. Basu says:

    March 1st, 2010 at 2:40 pm (#)

    In science (elsewhere too?) “right” and “wrong” are not absolute qualities. They change with time. What was right once, e.g. Newton's laws, can be replaced by something more right, e.g. Relativistic Dynamics a la Einstein. As a result, the entire body of scientific literature is a mish-mash of right and wrong. Ideas are correct in some limited way. And yes, all those papers can be thought to be an ever increasing encyclopedia of errors.

  14. Hang says:

    March 1st, 2010 at 7:29 pm (#)

    I was probably a bit unclear in my post. The phenomena I was talking about was the one where people first realize that there's a bias against wrong ideas and think “well, I'm going to *fix* this once and for all and it will be a great boon to society and bootstrap progress to the next level because never again will people fail to aware of wrong ideas again”.

    This is a supreme irony because they are falling into the exact same trap that they were just made aware of. They're walking over the corpses of a thousand other people who tried the exact same thing after the exact same realization and there's something both deeply funny and deeply sad about this that I couldn't resist mentioning.

  15. Chuangbbb says:

    November 10th, 2011 at 8:52 am (#)

    Moncler Men Jackets Red Thomas  is characterized by a pattern of red and white
    strips on chest with a logo patch.
    [url=http://www.monclerjacketssale-cheap.com/]moncler jackets sale cheap[/url] moncler
    jackets cheap. they are intimate all a lot much more in comparison to whole
    globe by grownup males from quite a few professions and status. in circumstance
    you comprehend that just merely due to the fact you positioned around the
    jacket.

    Moncler Accordance within our affluence
    acclimation bogus is definitely the plenty of acclimated adeptness in 2010,
    apish architectonics [url=http://www.monclerjacketssale-cheap.com/]moncler
    jackets cheap[/url] adeptness that could bender accepting aloof about any brace
    of jeans and aswell aeriform slacks beautifully, Now you can rest your worries [url=http://www.monclerjacketsonline-sale.com/]moncler
    jackets[/url] and pick a moncler jacket. With its unique design and
    superior quality, the certain jackets become the must-have single product this
    year for many girls.

    Are you a girl who chase about the low
    profile beauty? Then choose the moncler jacket ?and enjoy the beauty all
    through your life.

    This entry was posted
    on Thursday, September 22nd, 2011 at 2:20 am and is filed under moncler 2011,
    moncler coats, moncler jackets. You can follow any [url=http://www.monclerjacketsonline-sale.com/]moncler
    jackets online sale[/url]  responses
    to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback
    from your own site.

  16. The persistently stupid idea « Bumblebee Labs Blog says:

    April 1st, 2010 at 1:23 pm (#)

    […] There are only three types of ideas. […]

  17. Twitter, I finally get you. · The Daily Bones says:

    April 27th, 2010 at 5:24 pm (#)

    […] It was during my thoughts around this last point that I realized the true allure and power of Twitter. The middle-men connecting the average person with anyone has been removed, whether they know them personally or not. First off – I in no way assume this has not been thought of before, or never been discussed; as I’m a firm believer that anything you think of is either unoriginal or wrong. […]

  18. Harold Jarche » Some unoriginal and wrong thoughts says:

    August 20th, 2010 at 3:53 am (#)

    […] “Anything you think is either unoriginal, wrong or both” […]

  19. Harold Jarche » Quotes from 2010 says:

    December 27th, 2010 at 2:55 pm (#)

    […] “Anything you think is either unoriginal, wrong or both” […]

  20. designerhandbagsoutlet says:

    September 25th, 2011 at 1:23 am (#)

    A great post but How to select a cool shoes. we sell cheap shoes We are the best store provided various  cheap designer shoes but only a little white to make coach shoes online

  21. cheap designer shoes says:

    October 9th, 2011 at 11:54 am (#)

    Thanks for your opinion. discount shoes I totally like with it.I like cheap designer shoes as well and someone is looking for cheap shoes online People usually prefer cheap shoes, especially when they visit some designer shoes. In some areas,people like to wholesale clothing. They will find some store doing very cheap or discounted shoes outlet. Certainly,  is a good way to earn money.
    designer shoes outlet

  22. Buy domain India says:

    October 13th, 2011 at 1:47 pm (#)

    Good work. Most of the time, I have thought both. Simply I have thought but you have analysed it. Great to be here…

  23. Irctcpnrstatus says:

    October 15th, 2011 at 12:26 pm (#)

    very well write – nice post – 

  24. Chuangbbb says:

    February 22nd, 2012 at 6:14 am (#)

    See today called the English
    version of a "small yue yue" incident reports, may trigger a
    "small yue yue" event in Chinese in heart’s pain. Out of the
    noble moral yearning, people always Chad
    Muska Skytop
     
    hope that the moral
    Jordan
    1 Flight Mid
    event can play the role of spots
    Muska
    Skytop High Tops
    and, promote the whole social moral
    further, the principle on one building Supra
    Vaider Shoes
     
    People always want to happen and
    moral of the low incident, don’t face to point and the social moral all into
    disrepute.

      Say to the "small yue yue"
    Jordan
    4 Retro
    event, is still the heartache of people, the
    scene is never forget.

    Two years of foshan get run
    over girls small yue yue, in the house by a van near knocked down and two
    rolling, trouble-causing car after a minute to escape, a car HuoGuiChe over
    Air
    Jordan Retro 11
    again was small and medium-sized
    Jordan
    2 Retro Candy
    jinfenshijia will young body… After
    the accident just six minutes, the girl was repeatedly rolling, there have been
    Jordan
    Retro 3
    18 from passers-by jinfenshijia will close by,
    no one moves to help, and even no one call for help phone! Until 6 minutes and
    27 seconds, a SheHuang aunt until the small jinfenshijia will picked
    up.

      At that time, the TV play this tragedy scene
    again and again.

    Now, I think such a play
    method, such a Nike
    Air Jordan 6 Retro
    rendering, seemed a bit cruel, and
    even a little immoral.

    Now, I think it 18
    Supra
    Skytop 3
    passers-by become public opinion attack
    target, one sure there is a being set up, because no one can guarantee in so
    dim the road, all passers-by will found the ground of small yue yue.

    Now, I think "small
    yue yue" event triggered social moral big thinking is very meaningful.
    But, even though the 18 people moral all need to save, also can’t so that all
    the social morality has the collapse of Supra
    Henry Boot Shoes
    conclusion.

    Trigger this
    "exclamation, see today called the English version of a"
    small yue yue "incident reports.

    According to Hong Kong’s
    Jordan
    Retro 9
    Ming pao news Supra
    Vaider High Tops
    reports, the Chinese mainland last
    year there little jinfenshijia Jordan
    5 Fusion
    will die storm, moving to cool the moral
    issues and thin, similar situation in the UK now also occur. Britain is a
    14-year-old boy on his way to school last week, in the electrical station
    faint, lie down on the platform for 10 minutes, the morning Jordan
    Retro 8
     
    rush of electricity in time the
    Supra
    TK Society High Tops
    station to no one to help, the
    boy mother Supra
    Society Mid Shoes
    anger boom act, accused the social
    cool thin.

  25. cheap shoes online says:

    October 16th, 2011 at 6:30 am (#)

    Thanks for your opinion. discount shoes I totally like with it.I like cheap designer shoes as well and someone is looking for cheap shoes People usually prefer fake designer shoes, especially when they visit some shoes outlet. In some areas,people like to wholesale clothing. They will find some store doing very cheap or discounted Chanel shoes outlet. Certainly,  is a good way to earn money.designer shoes outlet

  26. Anonymous says:

    October 21st, 2011 at 6:56 am (#)

    Thanks for these great resources

    Great article. Waiting for more.
    Grey’s Anatomy Season 7

     

  27. cheap domain registration says:

    October 21st, 2011 at 9:14 am (#)

    Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.

  28. cheap domain registration says:

    October 21st, 2011 at 9:14 am (#)

    Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.

  29. domain registration says:

    October 21st, 2011 at 9:16 am (#)

    We provide services of Cheap Domain Registration and Cheap Web Hosting Company in India. domain booking through debit card | domain registration with debit card | domain registration | domain booking through debit card | domain registration with debit card | domain name registration | website registration | register domain name

  30. domain registration says:

    October 21st, 2011 at 9:17 am (#)

    We provide services of Cheap Domain Registration and Cheap Web Hosting Company in India. domain booking through debit card | domain registration with debit card | domain registration | domain booking through debit card | domain registration with debit card | domain name registration | website registration | register domain name

  31. domain through debit card says:

    October 21st, 2011 at 9:17 am (#)

    Thanks a lot for sharing this useful and attractive information and I will be waiting for other interesting posts from you in the nearest future.keep it up.

  32. domain through debit card says:

    October 21st, 2011 at 9:17 am (#)

    Thanks a lot for sharing this useful and attractive information and I will be waiting for other interesting posts from you in the nearest future.keep it up.

  33. domain booking with debit card says:

    October 21st, 2011 at 9:18 am (#)

    Excellent information.. which I believe will be very useful for me.

  34. domain booking with debit card says:

    October 21st, 2011 at 9:18 am (#)

    Excellent information.. which I believe will be very useful for me.

  35. domain booking with debit card says:

    October 21st, 2011 at 9:20 am (#)

    We provide services of Cheap Domain Registration and Cheap Web Hosting Company in India. domain booking through debit card | domain registration with debit card | domain registration | domain booking through debit card

  36. domain booking with debit card says:

    October 21st, 2011 at 9:20 am (#)

    We provide services of Cheap Domain Registration and Cheap Web Hosting Company in India. domain booking through debit card | domain registration with debit card | domain registration | domain booking through debit card

  37. domain booking with debit card says:

    October 21st, 2011 at 9:22 am (#)

    Thanks a lot for sharing this useful and attractive information and I will be waiting for other interesting posts from you in the nearest future.keep it up.

  38. domain booking with debit card says:

    October 21st, 2011 at 9:22 am (#)

    Thanks a lot for sharing this useful and attractive information and I will be waiting for other interesting posts from you in the nearest future.keep it up.

  39. domain booking with debit card says:

    October 21st, 2011 at 9:22 am (#)

    Thanks a lot for sharing this useful and attractive information and I will be waiting for other interesting posts from you in the nearest future.keep it up.

  40. süper dragon geciktirici says:

    November 12th, 2011 at 6:07 pm (#)

    kadın çirkini ya 😀

  41. Domain register says:

    December 22nd, 2011 at 1:55 pm (#)

    Excellent read, Great job,keep sharing more articles like this

  42. Nicholas J. Donalds says:

    July 21st, 2012 at 5:18 am (#)

    I got to your site by first thinking of a name for my site “figuring shit out”. You had the site already. I don’t mind, but I find it fascinating that I read this post because my idea had obviously been unoriginal, unfortunately. It’s a good name! Whenever I have an idea, I google it and it’s usually already out there. What do we do?

  43. buy diablo 3 gold says:

    October 27th, 2012 at 7:43 am (#)

    Diablo 3 patch 1.0.5 has been available for several day, almost Diablo 3 players have focused on the changes of this new patch. It’s no doubt that Inferno machine and Monster Power system have been the centre of this new patch. However, you should not miss the important part in this patch – hotfixes. And the key of the hotfixes must be the trail of cinders fix.

    Hope you can enjoy the game with these hotfixes. And if you need to buy Diablo 3 gold or any other items in playing the game, welcome to CheapDiablo.

  44. gold jewelry online says:

    April 30th, 2017 at 3:16 pm (#)

    Thank you for every other excellent post. Where else could anybody get that kind
    of info in such a perfect way of writing? I have a presentation next week, and I
    am at the look for such information.

  45. JimmiNu says:

    September 8th, 2017 at 12:34 pm (#)

    8AQNXe http://www.FyLitCl7Pf7ojQdDUOLQOuaxTXbj5iNG.com

Leave a Response